← thinking · post

no one is wrong on purpose

When having conversations with people you disagree with:

1- If you think people are not wrong on purpose and they believe earnestly what they believe and they came to the views they have in good faith, it puts you in a mindset to be able to communicate with them in a much less confrontational way.

2- If you approach people as if somehow they are defective or evil, you are not gonna find the common ground that you need to get through them.

3- Use “Steel Man” instead of “Straw Man” approach when debating others you disagree with

“Steel Man” is:

A debate technique that involves presenting an opponent’s argument in its strongest form, even if that’s not how they presented it.

Example: Someone claims: “Money is the key to happiness.”

to Steel Man this claim: You have to think about that claim is true and argue as if you believe it’s true: “I might not agree that money is the key to happiness, but I do recognize that it can provide security, resources and opportunities for a more fulfilling life.”

So we actively engage in their argument in good faith.

“Straw Man” is:

A logical fallacy that involves creating a distorted or exaggerated version of an opposing argument and then attacking that version.

Example: Someone claims: “Money is the key to happiness.”

to Straw Man this claim: “Oh, so if money is the key to happiness, I guess you’re saying the anybody with wealth has never experience sadness or had any problems ever.”

The Straw Man diminishes the nuance and reduces it to an easily defeatable position.

the newsletter

Get the next one in your inbox

Essays on building, craft, and staying in the game. One email when I publish something worth your time, and nothing in between.

Free, on Substack. Unsubscribe whenever, no hard feelings.